Canadian Health Coalition
  • Donate
  • Menu Canvas
    • CHC Home
    • News
    • About us
    • Campaigns
    • Take action
    • Contact
  • hello@healthcoalition.ca
  • 343-558-1788
Donate OR Subscribe
    • English
    • Français (French)
Canadian Health Coalition
  • Home
  • About us
    • Our Team
  • News
  • Campaigns
  • Take action
  • Contact
  • Donate

    Support the Canadian Health Coalition

    $
    Select Payment Method
    Personal Info

    Credit Card Info
    This is a secure SSL encrypted payment.

    Donation Total: $55.00 One Time

Supreme Court of Canada should toss private clinic’s case against B.C. Medicare

Homepage Commentary Supreme Court of Canada should toss private clinic's case against B.C. Medicare
Commentary

Supreme Court of Canada should toss private clinic’s case against B.C. Medicare

December 7, 2022
By Steven Staples
0 Comment
885 Views

Public health care advocates are watching developments closely as the Supreme Court of Canada considers a private corporation’s request to appeal its failed constitutional case against the British Columbia Medicare Protection Act.

Last week, the B.C. Attorney General urged the Supreme Court of Canada to dismiss Cambie Surgeries Corporation’s application for leave to appeal a ruling by B.C. Courts, saying, “The present case raises no legal issue of national or public importance, and that leave to appeal should be denied [emphasis in original].”

Cambie Surgeries launched a case against the B.C. Medicare Protection Act arguing it unfairly denies patients the right to timely care. In September 2020, the B.C. Supreme Court’s Justice John J. Steeves ruled against the private, for-profit corporation.

“The expert evidence (including from the plaintiffs’ experts) is that duplicative private healthcare would not decrease wait times in the public system and there is expert evidence that wait times would actually increase (paras. 2308‑2349). This would cause further inequitable access to timely care,” said Justice Steeve’s judgement, contradicting Cambie’s arguments.

  • Read “BC Court of Appeal dismisses challenge to Medicare Protection Act” by Pat Van Horne, published on July 20, 2022

Support the Canadian Health Coalition

Donate now

Cambie Surgeries appealed, arguing Justice Steeves’ had made critical errors of fact in denying its constitutional challenge. But in July, 2022, the B.C. Court of Appeal upheld Steeves’ judgement.

Undeterred by the court’s decision, Dr. Brian Day, the owner of Cambie Surgeries Corporation, seems to believe that the current crisis in the hospital sector could shift opinion in his favour of a two-tier system.

He recently used the pages of the Globe and Mail to argue that the terrible situation plaguing hospitals warrants access to options outside the public system if limits on patient wait times are exceeded. “If that time is exceeded, the government must fund care elsewhere, even if that involves funding private care or travel to another province or country,” he wrote.

The B.C. courts looked at the evidence thoroughly and concluded that an increased role for private, for-profit corporations like Cambie Surgeries will only make wait times longer by drawing health care workers away from public hospitals to private clinics. Even worse, the ensuing disparity of access will affect disadvantaged and marginalized communities much more that wealthier and privileged sectors of society.

In its submission to the Supreme Court of Canada, the B.C. Government argued, “The result would be a two-tier health care system where those who have the ability to access private treatment would receive preferential treatment over those who cannot, irrespective of medical need [emphasis in original].”

Public health care advocates are gearing up for Round 2 of the fight against Cambie’s push for more private, for-profit health care. Canadian Doctors for Medicare, the B.C. Nurses Union, the British Columbia Friends of Medicare Society, and others intervened in the case with support from many individuals and organizations including the Canadian Health Coalition.

It is anticipated that should the Supreme Court of Canada grant Cambie Surgeries Corporation leave to appeal, then public health care groups will similarly organize themselves to defend the public system. A response from the Supreme Court of Canada is expected early in the new year.

Steven Staples is the National Director of Policy and Advocacy for the Canadian Health Coalition
Tags: Privatization

Previous Story
Health files
Next Story
Take action for pharmacare

Related Articles

Canadians have three times more medical debt than Australians: poll

Health files | Private health care “wildly” more expensive

What the end of the Cambie legal saga means for public health care

Provinces are undermining public health care by outsourcing surgeries to...

Recent Posts

  • Budget 2023 overlooks Canada’s “dirty little secret” about federal health funding May 23, 2023
  • Canadians have three times more medical debt than Australians: poll May 23, 2023
  • Health and Hope Lobby 2023: What we heard and what’s next May 17, 2023
  • Those who suffer the most are the most vulnerable: Dakota Tipi Chief on racism in health care May 17, 2023
  • What the end of the Cambie legal saga means for public health care May 10, 2023

Tags

Canada Health Transfer Canadian Health Coalition COVID-19 Dental Care Federal Election 44 Health+Hope 2025 Health Care Workers Health Policy Home care Long-term Care Medicare Mental Health Pharmacare Plasma Privatization Racism Reproductive Health Care Solutions series
Canadian Health Coalition
116 Albert St. Suite 300
Ottawa, Ontario K1P 5G3
+343.558.1788
hello@healthcoalition.ca
  • Home
  • What we do
  • Campaigns
  • News
  • Contact

Find posts prior to January 1, 2021
SearchPostsLogin
Tuesday, 23, May
Budget 2023 overlooks Canada’s “dirty little secret” about federal health funding
Tuesday, 23, May
Canadians have three times more medical debt than Australians: poll
Wednesday, 17, May
Health and Hope Lobby 2023: What we heard and what’s next
Wednesday, 17, May
Those who suffer the most are the most vulnerable: Dakota Tipi Chief on racism in health care
Wednesday, 10, May
What the end of the Cambie legal saga means for public health care
Wednesday, 10, May
Council of Canadians raising the political temperature for public pharmacare

Welcome back,